Rosebank 1989 Signatory Vintage cask 723 + 724
Apparently there have been a few other Rosebank distilleries one time or other – one opened in the late 18th century by a pair of Stark brothers, another popped up in the early 19th century run by one James Robertson – it is unknown if this is the same distillery as the Stark’s. James Rankine built another in 1840, which is the Rosebank we know, built opposite the maltings of the old Camelon distillery across the canal, and now Scottish Canals (who bought over the site from Diageo in 1993) plans to revitalise the area by granting the abandoned buildings a new lease of life. In the works: Rosebank micro brewery. The name,it seems, does not give up the ghost so readily.
By all means this was a successful distillery, well located for transport, abundant water. James’ son R.W Rankine rebuilt Rosebank in 1864, and the next year went so far as to demolish Camelon distillery to expand the maltings for Rosebank’s use. The 2 sites were once connected by a bridge.
Times were less auspicious in 1914, when conditions precipitated by the war prompted the owners of Rosebank to merge with four other distilleries to form Scottish Malt Distillers, which of course became part of the future DCL and United Distillers, and by May 1993, United Distillers had closed Rosebank, leaving it to deteriorate sadly along the banks of the Forth & Clyde Canal. It’s fate was finally sealed in 2002 with its sale to Scottish Canals
Now the reputation of Rosebank is such that a few urban legends surround it’s ‘grievous loss’ (Michael Jackson). Chief among them is that United Distillers, in considering the lowland entry for their Classic Malts range, chose Glenkinchie over Rosebank not due to the quality of its malt but because Glenkinchie was prettier to the eye and deemed more attractive to visitors, whilst Rosebank bordered on industrial along a busy waterway. The question of quality of whisky is a nebulous one, not to cast aspersions on Glenkinchie’s malt, but enough well-regarded writers have commented on the superiority of Rosebank’s whisky that if anything, one walks away recognizing that there is no smoke without fire.
The triple stills (1 wash + 2 spirit) that produced this fine whisky were known to be ‘dumpy’shaped and utilised worm tubs present another mystery. Several sources have it that Rosebank was triple distilled till the end, yet:
One source (Brian Townsend’s Scotch Missed) claims triple distillation was used in Rosebank for decades, but according to Ulf Buxrud and the DCL archives partial triple distillation, much in the lines of Benrinnes, was used in the 20th century.
From here. It is a worthy mention that Jim Murray also believes Rosebank was 2.5 times distilled.
Alas the facts are lost to history, what you and I have left are liquid testament, at least while stocks last.
Rosebank 1989/2002, 05/04/1989 ~11/04/2002, Signatory Vintage, cask 723+724, 43%
Nose: Fresh pears and floral! Hugely scented with lots of little white and purple flowers on the kitchen table. It’s a sunny morning, with malt biscuits, cut pears and vanilla custard cream. Also new pine wood and citrus oil wood rub.
Palette: Fresh and zesty with lemon and prickly something – white pepper I think. Sweetly malted, biscuits and cream again, and new wood, but now getting sour will these herby dill and caraway flavours. It actually gets more and more sour. Lemony before the finish.
Finish: Long, lemon zest and white pepper.
Just look how pale and unadulterated it is. On the simple side but so clean and fresh, what you expect when you think refill lowland – it’s not the huge valentines bouquet, its the wildflower on the wall. Simple elegance.
Whiskyrific RSS
- Bunnahabhain 1974 / 2014 Samaroli Infinity #604 vs Bunnahabhain 1968 / 2002 Auld Acquaintance
- Glendullan 1997 Connoisseurs Choice vs Glen Keith 1993 Connoisseurs Choice
- Del Maguey San Pedro Taviche Mezcal vs Del Maguey Minero Mezcal
- Rosebank 21 yo 1992 Directors Cut Douglas Laing #10146 vs Rosebank 22 yo 1991 Mackillops Choice #271
- Laphroaig 34 yo 1975/2010 Gentle Noses #1035 Jack Weibers vs Laphroaig 20 yo 1965 Intertrade ~ 1985
- Clynelish 30 yo 1972 Murray McDavid 46% vs Clynelish 37 yo 1972/2009 The Whisky Exchange ’80 proof’ ‘Ten Years Online’ 46%
- Ardbeg 14 yo Cadenhead 80 proof vs Ardbeg 11 yo 1975/1986 Corti Brothers 86 proof
- Royal Brackla 18yo 1993/2012 Signatory #6755 vs Royal Lochnagar 23yo 1973/1997 Rare Malts
- Glenlivet ‘An Unbended All Malt’ Baretto import vs Glenlivet 1966 Gordon & Macphail
- Laphroaig 21 (200th Anniversary 2015) vs Laphroaig 17 yo 1987 for Monnier Trading
