Benrinnes, 23 yo, OB Special Release 2009
Yes this is the 2009, the 2014 was just released! Now’s the time to have a go at this one.
Benrinnes is a little different. As we know most modern Scottish malt distilleries practice double distillation, though Auchentoshan famously triple distills, which is generally taken as the ‘Lowland’ or ‘Irish’ style, even though not all Lowlanders or Irish triple distilled (And Talisker did till the 20s). But that’s not where we’re headed today.
There are a few odd ones out that have special distillation regimes – Mortlach famously makes use of their Wee Witchie to get the equivalent of 2.8 times distillation. Springbank does double distillation for Longrow, triple distillation for Hazelburn, and something close to 2.8 times distillation for regular Springbank. And Benrinnes, the last oddity on this short list also had a part triple distillation, at least from 1974 till 2007, when it was switched back to double distillation.
(from http://www.whiskystory.blogspot.com)
Benrinnes has 6 stills in a double three-still set up, a total of 2 wash, 2 intermediate and 2 spirit stills. The feints of the wash and spirit stills were redistilled in internmediate still, and the foreshots and heart of this intermediate still were fed into the receiver for the spirit still. The effect here is that the feints are given more copper contact in redistillation.
In 2007, the distillery reverted to double distillation without any change to the piping or still arrangement. The low wines were simply directed from the twin wash stills to their respective spirit stills and the 2 intermediate stills were paired as a wash and spirit still. Diageo says this was done to meet the needs of the blending team, and that Benrinnes retains its ‘complex meaty character’, though I suspect they just need more blending whisky.
Benrinnes, 23 yo, OB Special Release 2009 58.8%
(Commercial image – thanks TWE)
Label blurb: High up at 700 feet on the flank of Speyside’s noblest peark. Benrinnes commands a view of the heathery moorland and draws mountain water from the granite bed scurran and rowantree burns. Partial triple-distillation and the use of a traditional worm tub to cool the spirit help bring out its considerable character, which is further developed here by ageing in sherry wood. Muscular and lightly smoky, this big full-bodied after-dinner malt has concentrated sweetness, superb balance and an exceptionally long, dry and warming finish.
Nose: Dry sherry, not that much cocoa and the dried fruit is not sweet but deep, earthy and intense. I get compost and tree bark shavings, also ‘medicated’ tree resin too, a very organic kind of sherry nose. Also clearly a big bodied malt, with something that does suggest cured ham, which almost seems like sulphur here. With water: Opens up but it’s the same nose, a little sweeter maybe.
Palette: Not sweet but salted and mentholated dried dark DARK fruit plus thick meat sauce, in fact, a really roasty, gamey meat sauce full of hot metal and char, and with a ‘stink’ about it that says a roasted wild boar was and left in the still. (hope it’s not the cork.) The menthol grows and it gets drier and more savoury. A weighty spirit, but straightforward on the tongue.
Finish: Fairly long, savoury/earthy herbal dryness.
A big sherried whisky without sweetness, who would have thought. Still, it makes you wonder if this savouriness has something to do with the extra distillation on the feints, as both Mortlach and Benrinnes are known for a particular meaty quality.
Whiskyrific RSS
- Bowmore 16 yo Cadenhead Sheriff’s Bowmore Distillery 46% vs Bowmore 13 yo Cadenhead Sheriff’s Bowmore Distillery 80 proof
- Ardbeg Provenance 2nd Release for the US 23 yo 1974 / 1998 54.7% vs Ardbeg Provenance 1st release 23 yo 1974 / 1997 55.6%
- Strathisla 1965 / 2011 #3473 vs Tamdhu 21 yo 1990 Old & Rare Douglas Laing
- Strathisla 34 yo 1937 / 1972 Gordon and Macphail for Pinerolo 43% vs Macallan 1947 securo cap Campbell, Hope & King for Rinaldi 80 proof
- Pechuga Del Maguey PEC-131 49% vs Pierde Almas Conejo 2015 Lote: 06-PC 51%
- Gilbey’s Redbreast 12 yo , John Jameson & Son Liqueur Whiskey vs Jameson 15 yo Limited Millenium Edition 1984 / 2000 vs Daly’s Tullamore Distillery 38 yo 1952 -1991 Cadenhead 68.9%
- Dalwhinnie 25 yo 1987 / 2012 Special Release 52.1% vs Dalwhinnie 29 yo 1973 / 2003 Special Release 57.8%
- Glenfiddich-Glenlivet 30 yo 1963 / 1993 Cadenhead 51.7% vs Glenfiddich 1974 / 2002 50th Anniversary Of The Coronation Of HM Queen Elizabeth II #2336 48.9%
- Edradour 10 yo The Distillery Edition vs Edradour Ballechin 4 The Discovery Series
- Rosebank 22 yo 1990 / 2012 #93361 Chieftains vs Rosebank 30 yo 1974 / 2005 #1595 Douglas Laing Old Malt Cask for Alambic 55.6%
