Royal Brackla 18yo 1993/2012 Signatory #6755 vs Royal Lochnagar 23yo 1973/1997 Rare Malts
For want of sufficient samples of both royal distilleries, I’ve gone and put them together. Not sure it’s really a good idea as we know Royal Brackla is prime blending malt and distilled to be so, while Royal Lochnagar is known to be a characterful highlander.
Royal Brackla 18yo 1993/2012 Signatory #6755 53.3%
Nose: It’s a perfectly malty, slightly dusty malt with a round cereal-sweet core. Plenty of oatcakes plus butter and light honey. Some pollen, naught but a touch of minerals. Rather firm and not ‘floppy’. Plenty of denseness to give it backbone despite all its glorious nakedness. Plenty of muesli dust mixed with a dry herbal dust, like the bottom of a packet of bouquet garni. This has so much charm in itself, I will never understand why some people like sherry so much.
Palate: Is as the nose suggests, but packed quite some heat as well. Grated ginger and white pepper provides a white glow that eventually eases into dusty malt and honey again. Very firm.
Finish: Medium long, dry white heat, dusty, malty, cereals, very natural.
Royal Lochnagar 23yo 1973/1997 Rare Malts 59.7%
Some of the whiskies in this Rare Malts range were downright brutal.
Nose: Oops this may have done the Brackla in. Immediately old school and a lot more going on as well. Light phenolics of WD40, slightly rusty tin boxes, caked earth, heaps of dried out broken branches, more than a casual lick of smoke. Again a dense firm core that speaks of slightly fermenty fruit and dried leaves. Dried oak staves.
Palate: Metallic, metal polish, and grease. Old wood, black pepper and slightly camphorous. Shrivelled ginger. Dried up caked earth on shovels, feels just a tad peated although I can’t be sure. Dried paper, crumbling leather, and old smoke. Very old school , in fact I want to say very typically old school but it’s also just that. Lacking a bit of excitement.
Finish: Long, lightly phenolic again, no change to these notes.
Whiskyrific RSS
- Laphroaig 40 yo 1960 / 2001 42.4% vs Laphroaig 28 yo 44.4% (2018)
- West Indies Dark Rum 1948 Samaroli 49% vs Lapalun Rhum Petit-Bourg Vieux Rhum dela Martinique 1952 / 1972 50%
- Dornoch New Make August 2019 60% vs Dornoch New Make 63.5% ~ circa April 2018
- Tobermory 32 yo 1972 / 2005 49.5% vs Tormore 16 yo 1966 / 1982 Samaroli 57%
- Macallan 17 yo 1965 43% ~ bottled 1983 vs Macallan 29 yo 1965 / 1994 Signatory #1058 49%
- St. Magdalene 26 yo Cadenhead 1982 / 2008 52.7% vs St. Magdalene 32 yo Cadenhead 1982 / 2015 58.1%
- Aultmore 2005 / 2018 Gordon & Macphail #15601007 for Whiskywarehouse Exclusive 54.1% vs Aultmore 25 yo 46% ~ 2014 bottling
- Longrow 16 yo 1974 46% ~ mini, J & A Mitchell & Co Ltdvs Longrow 21 yo 1974 #1550 46%
- Lochside 21 yo 1979 / 2001 Silver Seal 50% vs Lochside 37 yo 1981 / 2018 The Whisky Agency 48.6%
- Lagavulin 10 yo 1988 / 1998 Horae Solaris Moon Import 50% vs Lagavulin 1988 Samaroli 56%
