Eastern Highland 1975 / 1988 Samaroli Fragments of Scotland 50% (Glen Garioch) vs Glen Garioch 17 yo 1975 James MacArthur’s 54.2%
Eastern Highland 1975 / 1988 Samaroli Fragments of Scotland 50% (Glen Garioch)
Just a note that Glen Garioch should not be compared to Islay. Peated with dry earth and chunks of coal but by no means massive, in fact it leans towards leanness. Dry newspaper, smoky vetiver roots, lamp soot, dry rocks and dusty red earth. Though while not huge, its very direct and brings the goods one after another. Charcoal and cold tar. Petrichor, juniper bark and other aromatic twigs thrown into fires. Road salt and dirty gravel towards the finish. Compact and austere in a peated highland sort of way. 91 pts
Glen Garioch 17 yo 1975 James MacArthur’s 54.2%
Still peaty though much less peated and less phenolic now. More wood and somewhat sweeter or rounder. Still we get cold ash, black tea and spilt ink vibes. Again not massive but leaning towards a thin austerity. Butane as it ignites, smoky caramel and dry firewood in a fire. Hot stones and embers on which burnt capsicums and a thai basil and black pepper sauce was made. Surprisingly hot on the palate. 86 pts
Whiskyrific RSS
- Balvenie 15 yo 1974 / 1990 Signatory #18103-18130 57.1% vs Balvenie SMWS 40.1 1976 / 1997 60.6%
- White Horse America’s Cup 43% vs Pillaged Malt 10 yo Vatted Malt 57.1% ~ 1st edition bottled 2003
- Teaninich 19 yo That Boutique-y Whisky Company Batch 1 48.6% vs Teaninich 32 yo 1983 Adelphi #6738 47.8%
- Bowmore 24 yo 1991 Carn Mor #616 54.9% vs Bowmore 25 yo 1989 Douglas Laing Old Particular #10581 55.1%
- Irish Single Malt Whiskey 24 yo Batch 1 That Boutique-y Whisky Company 46.8% vs Limerick Slaney Malt Irish 23 yo 1991 / 2005 Adelphi #8585 59%
- Isle of Jura 30 yo 1966 / 1996 Signatory #1868/69 52.6% vs Isle of Jura 30 yo 1966 / 1996 Kingsbury #1867 49.7%
- Rosebank 1991 / 2009 Gordon & Macphail #2119/2120/2121 55.3% vs Rosebank 21 yo 1989 / 2010 Lombard for Three Rivers #866 58.1%
- Ben Nevis 19 yo 1996 Distiller’s Art 48% vs Ben Nevis 20 yo 1995 Gleann Mor #11308 53.4% vs Ben Nevis 22 yo 1992 Cadenhead 53.5%
- Lagavulin 25 yo 200th Anniversary 51.7% ~2016 vs Lagavulin 30 yo 52.6% ~ 2006
- Craigellachie 31 yo Batch Batch 04-6137 52.2% vs Cragganmore 29 yo 1973 / 2003 Special Release 52.5%
